Year in Reading

A Year in Reading: Carolyn Kellogg

By posted at 11:23 am on December 19, 2009 4

Each time I talk about two of my favorite books this year, I find myself discussing what people wanted from them as much as the books themselves. I adored them both, but both seem to need positioning.

coverTake Chronic City by Jonathan Lethem. It’s a novel of not-quite-real New York, in which a former child actor becomes friends with an obsessive fanatic/critic, threaded through with surrealism, a second-life-type game, esoteric cultural discussions, a romance or two and questions of identity and self. It is everything a novel can be: funny, smart, puzzling, engrossing, layered. It is very Lethem-ian, in that it is Philip K. Dick-ish, but it is more controlled and mature – more ambitious, even – than Dick. It works on several levels; it’s the kind of book that’s fun to talk about. What it isn’t is a noir pastiche with a detective with Tourette’s – there’s no need for Lethem to write Motherless Brooklyn again, but some people are stuck on it. Re-read Motherless Brooklyn if that’s what you want from Lethem — but you’ll be missing out.

coverAnd then there’s Thomas Pynchon’s Inherent Vice. A vocal Pynchon contingent loves big, perplexing Gravity’s Rainbow – talk about layers! – and looks down on The Crying of Lot 49. The Pynchonmanes like the intellectual challenge of his massive books, and they tend to balk against the straightforward elements of Inherent Vice, which has a relatively clear plotline and a likeable, stoned main character. I would argue that comprehensibility is not a fault, that this book is as full of giddy joy with language and ephemeral ideas as his others. Those who don’t see that are looking too close, but perhaps that’s because they (we) are the target: when you step back, the book reads as an argument against the ambitious digging of his ardent fans. It’s a 400-page case for living with mystery. Long may Pynchon’s seclusion reign.

More from A Year in Reading

The Millions' future depends on your support. Become a member today!

Share this article

More from the Millions

4 Responses to “A Year in Reading: Carolyn Kellogg”

  1. Mike McQuillian
    at 1:22 pm on December 19, 2009

    I desperately need to read Chronic City. I love Lethem, and all the mixed feelings about the book have my interest piqued.

  2. Edan
    at 1:40 pm on December 19, 2009

    You’re such a pothead, Carolyn!

    I’m reading Chronic City now, and really enjoying it (though I have some critiques, too). I actually don’t love Lethem’s previous work, so I’m happy about what feels different about his new novel. It’s crazy fun!

  3. Carolyn
    at 2:04 pm on December 21, 2009

    Mike, it’s interesting how mixed reviews can indicate there’s something more there than a book that gets universal acclaim.

    And Edan is right: it looks like I’ve come up with the pothead picks of 2009!

  4. Gabi Mendoza
    at 7:21 am on December 23, 2009

    Pynchon is an explorer. Lethem is a tourist.

Post a Response

Comments with unrelated links will be deleted. If you'd like to reach our readers, consider buying an advertisement instead.

Anonymous and pseudonymous comments that do not add to the conversation will be deleted at our discretion.

NEW COMMENTING RULE: Comments may be held for moderation and/or deleted. Whitelisted commenters will see their comments appear immediately. Don't be a jerk. We reserve the right to delete your comment or revoke commenting privileges for any reason we want.